|
From KA1FSB
Loop Antenna Dimensions
Determining Your Best Loop Design...
Have you been thinking about experimenting
with a loop antenna, but are not
sure you have enough space to put one up? Have you heard that loops come
in many "shapes and sizes" and are confused about what might work best
for you at your particular location? Would you like to see "at a glance"
if you have room for a loop? The simple
calculator below
uses the well-known standard formula for determining the total wire length
in feet for a single element (single turn), full wave
loop antenna, (length = 1005/MHz). It also calculates
measurements for:
- A square or diamond loop shape
- A rectangular shape with a 2:1 ratio,
(where the horizontal is longer than the
vertical length by a factor of 2)
- A delta or triangular loop shape
- A circular shape
in the HF and VHF Amateur Radio bands. NOTE: All results
may be presented in either feet, meters, or centimeters.
(See Hints and Tips below for suggestions about
actual construction techniques...)
|
The purpose
of the calculator is to give you a quick overview of the feasibility
of "squeezing" a loop into your available yard or apartment space.
The calculator yields a reasonable approximation of dimensions, to
within 5% over the amateur bands, using typical wire gauges
ranging from #12-18 AWG. (It does not calculate inductance,
impedance, or even "Q" factor values since it is assumed that tuning will be
accomplished using open feeds and a transmatching device, which
should more than adequately compensate for the range of construction and
materials variations as measured by these parameters.)
As a reminder, it always displays the "standard"
input (feedpoint) impedance for a full wave loop, which of course
will vary slightly depending on materials and location. And, a few extra
features, a selector for dimension types, meters, or feet; and a mid-band
calculation, have been added to the JavaScript code.
These measurements should be able to tell you at a glance if you have
room for a loop! I hope so... loops make great antennas! (NOTE: You may
deduct 29.3% (0.293) from all vertical lengths if you decide to slope the
antenna away from the vertical plane by 45 degrees; see table below. Don't
forget to include an additional height above ground for the lowest
horizontal element when determining the total vertical dimension, usually
six or seven feet for safety reasons, i.e., people.)
To see how the calculator works, click on the
"Random Sample" Button. Or, enter a value in the Frequency
(megaHertz) text box, the Band text box, or the Wire Length text box,
and then click on "Calculate Dimensions" to see the values you are
interested in...
Repeatedly pressing the "Mid-Band"
button displays the wire lengths, and design dimensions, for the center
frequency in each of the amateur bands in turn. (A single press for any
given frequency, occurring within a valid amateur band, will also show
its mid-frequency point for that band range. The symbols ">" and "<"
indicate out-of-band conditions, hence no mid-band frequencies are
calculated...)
Pressing the "Mid-Band" button after entering a wire length, will
identify the lowest frequency loop, or largest antenna size, within
an amateur band. (A subsequent press will calculate the actual mid-band
dimensions for that band as usual.)
NOTE
: Wire lengths for a mid-band frequency may prove to
be the most practical since you may tune above or below to obtain
full coverage over the entire band! (The probable exception here would be
the 160m band. Tuning down from the mid-point might place a tuner box under
considerable electrical "strain" and would not be recommended. So, you
can't "cheat" at 160m, you will most likely need the full loop for its
lower band edge frequency.)
|
For a broader discussion of antennas used in packet radio, please see
Packet Radio Antennas. Here several types of popular VHF and UHF
antennas will be listed...
|
Loop Calculator:
A Few Operating Notes
:
- The conversion factor, as applied in feet-to-meters calculations, is:
0.3048
- The value used here for the cosine of 45 degrees is: 0.7071
- The wire gauge, most frequently cited by the research articles, was:
#14 AWG. (Please see "Construction Hints & Tips"
below... ) Thanks to Steve, G0SGB for keeping me honest :)
- Geometry buffs might notice an equivalency between the side of a square
and the height of the square's diagonal when sloped at 45 degrees. This
implies that a vertical square loop has the same height as a 45 degree
sloping diamond square loop. (Interesting :) For radio buffs, this means
that you only need one support if you use the sloping diamond shape. Are
these two antennas comparable in performance? A good research question!
The sloper certainly has a larger "footprint" and possibly a significantly
different radiation pattern.
|
Construction Hints & Tips:
- "What Size Wire Should I Use?"
-
There are several factors to consider when choosing
your wire gauge and type. As you know there is solid, stranded, covered
or insulated, and bare. A general principle is: as you move up in
frequency, wire size and type matter! As you move down in frequency, these
parameters become much less critical, or even relevant! For example, for an
80m loop, the diameter of the wire compared to its length is going to be a
very small ratio. And, it is this ratio that plays a key role in determining
the inductance of the antenna. So even if you double or half the size of the
wire, the outcome is not going to be significant enough to be concerned
about at these very long lengths of wire...
However, for a loop approaching the microwave region, wire size and
type become central to the design of the antenna! The formula
noted above, for the length of the loop, is probably not going to be
very accurate in this regard. Special formulas would be needed to take
all the physical variations into account, and predict its performance.
(Even fairly wide variations will probably be noticed in the 2m and 70cm
regions as well, despite the fact that the standard length formula is
often still recommended! You might consider using more appropriate
formulas in these cases... )
So, to make a long story short, #14 AWG is probably a good "bet." In most
of my primary sources; this is the gauge most frequently used in the HF
region. For VHF, #10-12 seems to be very popular. But, follow your plans
or specifications to the "letter" if you are working from schematics.
(Here are some plans for a
quad VHF antenna
which is working here on 145.070.)
- "What Type of Wire Should I Use?"
-
Again, the general rule still applies: the longer
the antenna element, the less it matters; and the shorter, the more it
matters! We all know that covered wire usually "appears" longer electrically
than bare wire. But, there are practical considerations too. Covered or
insulated wire holds up better when exposed to the elements. And sometimes
the tough, plastic covering on the wire can help to act as a strain relief
for the antenna if so constructed. For this class of outdoor suspended HF
antenna, stranded wire is probably best since it will flex with the wind
and not begin to work itself apart as solid wire would. And if the wire is
covered (insulated), you won't need quite as much of it as if it were bare.
If you are putting up an indoor antenna in your attic, for example, you
could probably use bare wire, either stranded or solid since there will
be no wind loading to be concerned about. If you use bare wire, common sense
dictates that you use good quality insulators as "stand offs" to prevent
adjacent materials from overheating. (Very large currents can circulate in
loop antennas, and wires can get quite warm!)
So generally for the HF bands, stranded wire, covered or bare, is a good
choice. At VHF, you may use solid wire. This may even help in offering some
extra support for your wire struts when on a beam or quad design. In most
cases, there will be a minimum of flexing due to wind with solid wire.
And, it may be covered or not. (If covered, then it will "appear longer"
than if uncovered, and you may need to take this into account when
trimming it up for resonance. In other words, the resonant frequency
may be lower than indicated by the calculation.)
- Supporting Your Loop Antenna
-
There are two types of support connectors
that can be used for HF loop antennas at the insulators: fixed and floating.
Fixed ensures that the wire will not slide through the insulator. You can
use another short piece of wire to twist around both sides of the loop
wire, thus "grasping" the insulator and preventing any movement. You
might want to use this type of connection near or at your feedpoint. The
other type speaks for itself; the wire is free to move through the
insulator and is considered a floating connection. This might be the
best type when using a horizontal loop that is supported by ropes
tied to "potentially swaying" trees.
For VHF, all points of contact with the supporting struts must be securely
fastened. I have used everything from electrical tape to heavy twine on
indoor antennas, and plastic ties to small hose clamps on outdoor quads.
Here is a problem with a wide range of solutions. Let you imagination be
your guide...
- Conclusions
-
Deciding to put up a loop antenna can be more of
a logistical problem than an engineering problem in the initial phases of
your project planning. I hope the calculator helps you with the logistical
part, and gets you thinking about the engineering part. This page can be
considered as a secondary source; so be sure to follow up on your
leads to primary engineering sources: such as text books, Ham Radio
publications, and professional journals; or computer programs
that have been specifically designed for radio engineering and mathmatical
analysis. A great deal is understood about loops, but there is probably
much more to be discovered as well... Your experience in loop building,
testing, and operating will not only benefit your own technical skill, but
can offer valuable insight and understanding to the field of RF
antenna design!
(Courtesy KBNorton Computer Systems)
|